|
SALTDEAN ASYLUM SEEKERS
HWhatever you views- this was a huge issue in Saltdean in
2003. I have archived it here for your interest.
- Evening Argus Tuesday 08 April 2003:
Asylum hotel plan scrapped. A seaside hotel will not be
used to house asylum-seekers after the Government backed
down on controversial plans. © Evening Argus
The Home Office has ruled out using the Grand Ocean Hotel
in Saltdean as an induction centre following months of controversy.
Home Office minister Beverley Hughes announced the hotel
had been ruled out for good, as had another hotel in Sittingbourne,
Kent. Although the induction centre programme would carry
on, existing arrangements would be expanded instead.
The decision was warmly welcomed by residents and councillors
who campaigned against the proposals. They argued Saltdean
did not have the resources to cope with an influx of refugees
and also feared a rise in crime.
The Argus revealed in November last year how the Home Office
had earmarked the hotel as emergency accommodation for refugees.
The Government first denied the plans but then backtracked,
blaming a "clerical error" for the previous announcement.
The proposals were put on ice in January following a crisis
meeting between Brighton and Hove City Council, Sussex Police,
the health authority and the National Asylum Support Service
(Nass). David Panter, city council chief executive, said:
"We are pleased to now have this clarity after all
the confusion created earlier in the year. "In talks
with the asylum service, the council always made it clear
we felt the hotel was unlikely to be suitable as an induction
centre. "However, we do recognise the problems the
Home Office has in finding appropriate accommodation and
overseeing a reasonable and measured debate." Kemp
Town Labour MP Des Turner said: "I am delighted the
Government has listened to local representations on this
issue. "There was a lack of infrastructure - for instance
there are not enough GP surgeries in Saltdean." Rottingdean
Tory councillor Lynda Hyde, whose ward covers the area,
said: "Saltdean has never been suitable for large numbers
of asylum-seekers. The Home Office has caused unnecessary
worry for the people of Saltdean. "Residents and councillors
have spent endless hours in fighting the proposal for such
large numbers."
Saltdean Residents Action Group was set up specifically
to fight the plans. Group member Greg Bishop, of Saltdean
Vale, said: "I think everyone will be pleased to hear
this announcement. "I just hope after all the U-turns
and people going back on their word, this decision will
be final." Green Party candidate Geoffrey Bowden said:
"We regret some people did not adopt a more civilised
and welcoming attitude in the first place. Instead, they
opted for a knee-jerk xenophobic approach." Marco Pasquale,
chief executive of the Grand Ocean Hotel Group, said in
February asylum-seekers would be allowed into the hotel
"over my dead body". Prime Minister Tony Blair
admitted to MPs in January that lack of consultation over
the hotel plans had been "inadequate and wrong".
Asylum-seekers typically spend between seven and ten days
at the induction centres before being dispersed around Britain.
l Another centre in Sussex used to detain asylum-seekers
and illegal immigrants has been criticised for "institutional
blindness". Tinsley House, based at Gatwick, holds
people waiting to be deported from the UK. Government inspectors
said the centre provided a "place of safety" with
a good standard of care. However, the inspection report,
which was published today, criticised staff for failing
to give detainees sufficient notice of what was happening
to them, or where they were to be sent next. Detainees were
also not given a chance to contact family, friends or legal
representatives.
- Hotel says no to asylum seekers© Evening Argus
27/02/03 by Krista Beighton
Managers of a seafront hotel near Brighton say it will
never be used to house asylum seekers. Staff at the Grand
Ocean Hotel in Saltdean said they had never been asked by
the Home Office to provide temporary accommodation for asylum
seekers. They said the hotel did not have suitable facilities
to provide such a service and any future government request
for it to do so would be refused. Marco Pasquale, chief
executive of the Grand Ocean Hotel Group, yesterday said
asylum seekers would be allowed into the hotel "over
my dead body". He said: "We have never and we
will never take asylum seekers. The Home Office has never
even approached us on this issue to ask if we would consider
it." Mr Pasquale said the hotel was not for sale and
no approaches had been made to buy it and change it into
a so-called induction centre for newly-arrived asylum seekers.
His comments were echoed in a statement from the hotel's
general manager David Regan, which read: "I would like
to confirm the hotel has never made any application to use
the hotel as an asylum seekers' home and has never applied
for a licence. "Our employees are very well motivated
but feel let down by recent events. We do not have suitable
facilities to provide such a service and we would not take
any business that would not fit in with our normal business.
"We are already 75 per cent full for this season and
attracting people to the area benefits the local traders,
all of whom are welcome to use our facilities. "I would
like to reiterate, we have never had this type of business
and do not intend to house such visitors in the future."
The National Asylum Support Service (NASS) put out a tender
stating it was looking for suitable property last year.
Harrow-based property company Leena Homes approached the
Home Office, suggesting it could block-book bedrooms at
the hotel. Brighton and Hove City Council were then notified
of the suggestion by the Home Office but Mr Pasquale said
he was never told of the negotiations. He said: "The
name Leena Homes only rings a bell with me because I read
it in reports in The Argus. They have certainly never approached
the hotel." The Home Office denied it was in negotiations
with Leena Homes when confronted by The Argus in November
last year. In January, we exclusively revealed the hotel
was to be used, with the Home Office blaming a "clerical
error" for the previous announcement. Yesterday, the
Home Office refused to discuss details of any dealings it
has had with property companies about the hotel. A spokeswoman
said: "We have not signed any contract on this hotel.
We would only do so after extensive consultation with the
council and members of the public. We are not currently
doing this." The council is still in negotiations with
NASS and the Home Office about the department's handling
of the issue.
Last Tuesday 18th Feb. Telscombe Town Council
Notice of Motion for Council 18th. February Telscombe Town
Council
This Council notes the failure of the Administration on
Brighton and Hove City Council to consult with both local
Town, District and County Councillors and the people of
Saltdean and Telscombe Cliffs on the agreement to use the
Grand Ocean Hotel as an induction centre for refugees.
It further notes the failure of the Government and the
National Association of Asylum Seekers to provide adequate
notice and information about the placement of refugees,
sufficient to allay the concerns that local people may have.
The council calls upon the City Council to;
1. Ensure that all information available to them will be
made available to the public and elected representatives
at the first opportunity.
2. Address legitimate concerns about numbers of refugees
and length of stay.
Finally that Telscombe Town Council:
1. Deplores the racist behaviour of some local people and
members of the BNP and commits itself to work with the police
to identify and report those seen to be acting in a racist
manner.
2. Commits itself to working with local agencies to ensure
that all refugees to this area are welcomed and given all
assistance to enable them to begin the process of readjustment
and adapting to a new life free from oppression and tyranny
such has been the tradition of this country to peoples seeking
respite from conflicts since the middle ages.
Thank you to everyone who signed the petition against the
use of The Grand Ocean Hotel for housing asylum seekers.
The petition with over 1600 signatures was handed in at
Downing Street with copies to NASS (who are responsible
for the decision) and Brighton and Hove Council.
Unfortunately, the plans are still going ahead and it seems
that the latest figures for the planned in take is in excess
of 250 asylum seekers. We must continue to fight the plans
as it is a simple fact Saltdean CAN'T cope!
Greg Bishop - Saltdean Vale
- Saltdean for Tolerance and Respect (STAR)
"Let's open our hearts and minds"
Press statement from Star
Saltdean residents say YES to asylum seekers. A meeting
took place in Saltdean on Sunday (9 February) to plan a
campaign to welcome refugees to the Grand Ocean Hotel.
Campaigners have been inundated by messages of support
since they took a stand against the anti-asylum seeker protest
at the hotel last month.
The meeting produced the following statement:
"Recent media coverage of events in our town has focussed
on the protests against the plan to accommodate asylum seekers
at a local hotel. These reports fail to represent the views
of the majority of local residents who have not signed petitions
or joined demonstrations.
"A meeting last weekend saw a cross section of the
Saltdean community discuss how we could promote a positive
view of refugees to our neighbours and plan activities to
welcome and support asylum seekers when they arrive in Saltdean.
"We welcome support from all those who are appalled
by the hysteria surrounding the asylum issue and would like
to help those willing to welcome refugees in Saltdean."
Readers can contact Saltdean for Tolerance and Respect
at: STAR, PO Box 164, Brighton, BN1 7WB
- Asylum Seekers - February 14th 2003 © Evening
Argus Asylum protest at No.10 by our news team
Campaigners objecting to the use of a Sussex hotel to house
asylum seekers went to Downing Street yesterday. They were
armed with two boxes of signatures supporting their protest.
Home Office plans to use the Ocean Hotel, in Saltdean, to
accommodate refugees have caused controversy since they
were announced last year. Councillor Lynda Hyde joined residents
handing over the 1,600 strong petition along with a letter
to the Prime Minister. Other residents have been supporting
a campaign to welcome asylum seekers. A group of 19 gathered
at the advice surgery of Brighton Kemptown MP Des Turner
last week, asking him to make a stand against the "racist
hysteria" surrounding asylum seekers. Raf Salkie, of
the Committee to Defend Asylum Seekers, said large seaside
hotels were an obvious place to run induction courses for
them..
- Protesters in asylum clash
by Barbara Davidson
Tempers frayed when hundreds of people took to the streets
to protest against plans to house asylum seekers in a Sussex
hotel. More than 250 people endured the rain to vent their
anger against the proposal.
Meanwhile, campaigners sympathetic to the asylum seekers
stood on the opposite side of the street, accusing them
of scaremongering. Police moved in when a 45-year-old woman
dressed in a camel coat crossed the road to confront protesters,
waving her own banner and urging residents to put themselves
in the asylum seekers' shoes. As the crowd shouted "go
home" and "do-gooder", a scuffle broke out
when she grabbed a protest poster and tore it up. She was,
in turn, hit over the head with a placard. Officers escorted
the woman away for her own safety as she was harangued by
a protester dressed as Osama Bin Laden.
Passing motorists honked their horns to show support for
those lining the road outside the Grand Ocean Hotel in Saltdean.
Banners read "Our village is not Sangatte", "Saltdean
can't Cope" and "Homes for our elderly not for
phoney asylum seekers. We have taken enough Mr Blair."
Most residents heaped blame on the Government for its mishandling
of the situation and called for more openness on exactly
who would be using the hotel. The Home Office wants to use
the Grand Ocean for emergency accommodation despite denying
the plan when it was first revealed by The Argus in November
last year. At present, the project is on ice following a
storm of protest from residents, even though the Government
retracted its earlier statement and said it wanted to use
the hotel after all.
Among the campaigners was resident Marc Curtis, who said
Saltdean did not have the infrastructure to take asylum
seekers in, adding: "How do you differentiate between
asylum seekers and illegal immigrants?" Phyllis Dunn
is one of many elderly residents living opposite the hotel.
She said: "We're scared to death. Everybody in these
flats is over 80 and some are in their 90s. Some say they'll
be afraid to go to the post office and get their pension."
The protest was organised through the Saltdean Residents'
Association. Committee vice-chairman Liz Kempshall said
people were angry at the lack of consultation, adding: "If
we knew the truth it would help considerably. "I think
this has come at a very bad time in the national press with
the ricin and everything and a lot of elderly people are
quite terrified." Resident Amanda Meighan said: "People
have had enough. We're not against genuine asylum seekers
but against those who don't have a right to be here that
the Government are letting in." But other residents
gathered opposite to voice their own protest at attitudes
towards asylum seekers and the "scaremongering"
surrounding the issue. Steve Waters, a former local GP,
said: "I've lived in Saltdean for 15 years and some
of these protesters are my ex-patients.
"I think there needs to be a rational debate, not
irrational scaremongering. I feel we need to respect our
fellow human beings." Simon Williams, community affairs
spokesperson for the Green Party, said: "Many of these
asylum seekers are vulnerable women and children and have
had traumatic journeys. This is a chance to show a welcoming
side to our city. "Local people do need to be reassured
but let us take it stage by stage and ensure the Government
provides the resources so no one loses out."
Saltdean councillor Liz Lee said: "My children are
mixed race and I do not want them growing up with hatred
around them. But the Government are so at fault in this.
The whole situation has been handled badly." Despite
feelings running high on both sides, the rest of the protest
passed by peacefully and no arrests were made.
- Protest & SRA Meeting January 25th 2003
The protest was attended by around 5-600 residents in the
morning and was peaceful apart from a minor fracas over
a placard that was blown out of all proportion by the media.
The protest lasted over an hour and a half and dispersed
peacefully. Lots of media were there (Southern Counties
Radio, The Argus etc etc.) There few protesters on both
sides although the car beeps and attendance on the 'asylum
seekers out' side vastly outweighed the others.
The SRA meeting began at 1.30 and the chair Evelyn George,
reported that it was the largest attendance for years (although
the last meeting must have come close). She stated that
Languard Alarms were offering a 50% discount to anyone booking
a security system if their leaflet was signed by a committee
member and Mrs George will continue to do this if in the
interest of local residents. She went on to welcome the
invited guests, Councillors Hyde, Smith, Hunt, Clayton and
our local MP Des Turner. Mrs George went onto reiterate
that the SRA was apolitical and that foul language was not
wanted. Also only one statement per person and all statement
to go through the chair. She also stated that it would be
nice to see people attend other meetings if they could.
The Resident - Duncan Ward explained that The Resident
which has come out this weekend in the leader and is available
at the Happy Shopper and the Post Offices was written before
the issue of Asylum Seekers blew up again so it was out
of date due to circumstances beyond SRA control.
Asylum Seekers - Dr Des Turner apologised to the floor
an explained that there had been confusion and that the
Home Office had stated that Saltdean was not an appropriate
place due to a number of reasons. He had been extremely
surprised over the Home Office U-turn. The National Asylum
Seeker Support Service (NASS) had had a change of staff
but this was still unacceptable. He underlined that there
had been NO contract signed by the hotel and wouldn't be
until a whole series of issues have been resolved. He was
quite optimistic that Saltdean would be turned down as an
induction centre but could give no guarantees. Sittingboune
( the other hotel in Kent in a similar position to the Ocean)
has apparently already signed a contract Counc. Smith addressed
the floor and referred to an unsigned statement put out
on Ocean Hotel paper that accused Couns. Hyde, Smith &
Clayton of stirring up trouble. He went onto question why
the Home Office was involved as many coastal hotel take
a small amount of asylum seekers. He also stated that he
felt local councillors had not been privy to Brighton and
Hove Council proceedings. He vigourously denied the claims
as slander.
One resident asked why there had been no consultation with
residents. The answer was that there was no formal consultative
process. Residents should write and voice their concerns
to Beverley Hughes, Minister of State at the Home Office.
Another resident asked if the Home Office was the sole
agent for discussion. Dr Turner answered that social services
and no direct role and that NASS was an 'arms length' government
agency. Although contract's needed signed ministerial approval
but we could complain to Des Turner who would campaign on
our behalf.
Councillor Hyde confirmed that local councillors had been
kept in the dark. She stated that she had been told that
although the project was supposed to have been on hold she
was told that there was an ongoing impact assessment on
Saltdean which seemed to contradict that.
One Resident stated that people were angry because they
felt that they were being kept in the dark. He stated that
Des Turner only tells us what he wants us to hear and that
we should keep the pressure up. Mrs George confirmed that
the pressure was certainly being kept up.
One resident queried whether representatives on Telscombe
Town Council were doing anything. Coun. Clayton confirmed
that letters had certainly been sent from T.T. Council,
including letters to Brighton and Hove Council requesting
information. Counc. Manning had written to Duncan ward and
has expressed his disgust and will be writing letters. Coun.
Clayton went onto say that he had had meetings with the
manager of the Ocean Hotel and been assured by him that
it was not being used for asylum seekers. He stated that
ESRA had had a social evening at the Ocean Hotel which had
been really well attended but went onto call ,what the manager
had said to him 'a pack of lies'.Counc. Lee of Telscombe
Cliffs also conformed that she has written to both B &
H council and the Ocean Hotel asking to be kept informed.
One resident expressed their disgust that 10 Labour councillors
had walked out of the meeting and their disgust at the excuse
of a clerical error being made.
One resident queried that links between the Ocean Hotel
and Arab Banks Plc based in Jersey. They queried a substantial
loss last year and their figures and debts of £21
million. Des Turner stated that he couldn't explain the
accounts. Some discussion had been made regarding a Leena(?)
homes but his was not confirmed or denied. Lots of companies
do offshore business he said. Mrs George stated that there
was nothing to stop any resident from finding out info from
company house.
Counc. Lee stated that she felt that the lack of information
had preyed on peoples fears and questioned whether 20 refugees
at the hotel was a problems the hotel had already been taking
bed and breakfast tenants for a while.
One resident stated he wished to work with the residents
of Saltdean to ensure that their fears would be groundless
question as to what Des Turner was doing was answered with
trying to voice complaints and work on behalf of residents
to prevent a contract and report progress when it came about.
A query as to whether the Manager of the Ocean Hotel was
invited was answered by Ms George with a no. Another query
about legal action by residents in Sittingbourne was clarified
by the fact that residents there were dealing with a signed
contract. Another local resident emphasised the need to
not have bigoted views.
Community centre - There was some discussion regarding
the community centre. Mrs George confirmed that we would
not be giving up the lease to the existing building until
the new building was ready to move into. They have agreed
square footage - something like 3200 - adequate for our
needs.
There was a reminder of the AGM Monday 28th April (AGM)
7.30pm where there will be nominations for committee members.
Treasurers Report was a total of around £16000 -
some of which is reserved for a lift. Counc. Lee had a reminder
to send letters off to DEFRA regarding the end of the South
Downs Boundary at the Tye and said that these needed to
be in by the end of February. You can print out the letters
here. There seems to be 8 sites and many of those are unlikely
so if they fail Portobello could come back on the agenda.
Secretaries report by Duncan ward included the need to support
the Taxi Rider which id the only link for some people to
Peacehaven from east Saltdean. He stated that at present
Brighton and Hove Council did not have the required funding
for an A259 roundabout but would update progress later on
- apparently B + H Council are getting a large fund that
may be used to pay the £50,000 balance needed.
The registrar said that number of members was rising with
local issues but we still needed collectors for many roads.
The social secretary reported that the Book sale would be
held on the 15th February. Helen Hicks from St Martins stated
that she would be going for planning permission for the
Barn for a Pre-school and afterschool club but they were
on the bottom rung of a very long ladder. She would be grateful
for any resident who could give her more history of the
barn. One resident asked if there would be a candidate from
The SRA running for election and Mrs George stated that
this was under consideration.
The meeting closed at 3.00 pm. Please email me here regarding
additions / amendments.
- Asylum Hotel Plan debated ©The Argus 24/01/03
by Adam Trimingham
Neighbours of a seafront hotel which could be used as emergency
accommodation for asylum seekers took their fears to city
leaders last night. A deputation from Saltdean went to Brighton
and Hove City Council to complain about the choice of the
Home Office of the Grand Ocean Hotel as an induction centre.
Resident Alan Hood urged the council to protest in the strongest
possible terms to the Home Office saying Saltdean would
be unable to cope with the influx of immigrants. He said:
"There has been an enormous response from the community
in Saltdean to the Home Office's proposal. People are scared
and frightened for the future of their community. "We
do not have objections to asylum seekers in principle and
sympathise with those seeking to build a new life away from
persecution and danger. "Our concerns arise because
the small residential area of Saltdean is not able to provide
the infrastructure to support the influx of a large number
people with the specific needs of asylum seekers."
Some Labour councillors walked out in protest during Mr
Hood's five-minute speech. Later, during councillors' question
time, council leader Ken Bodfish said the National Asylum
seekers' Service had not been efficient in dealing with
the Saltdean placements. He said the council had no role
in the process other than to work out whether the asylum
seekers would make great demands on local services. But
he said many asylum seekers in the past had contributed
greatly to the life of Britain. Asked by local Tory councillor
Lynda Hyde whether the Grand Ocean Hotel had been sold,
Coun Bodfish said he had no idea.
- Grand Ocean Hotel issues statement to the Argus kindly
posted to the website 22/01/03
Controversial plans to house asylum seekers in a seafront
hotel have been put on hold after a series of blunders by
the Government.
The Home Office wants to use the Grand Ocean Hotel in Saltdean
as emergency accommodation. It denied the plan when we first
revealed it in November last year. Then earlier this month
we exclusively revealed the hotel was to be used, with the
Home Office blaming a "clerical error" for the
previous announcement. Now the plan has been put on ice
following a storm of protests from residents in the Brighton
suburb, which is popular with elderly, retired couples.
The decision to delay was made yesterday following a crisis
meeting between Brighton and Hove City Council, police,
the health authority and officials from the National Asylum
Support Service (Nass). It came less than 48 hours after
Home Secretary David Blunkett accused the immigration and
nationality directorate of "incompetence" following
a row over similar plans for a hotel in Sittingbourne, Kent.
Council chief executive David Panter said afterwards: "We
received a clear commitment from the officials there would
be no placements in the hotel until, and unless, a package
of issues and concerns has been resolved. "It was a
very useful meeting, if at times tense. It was clearly taking
place in the light of events at the hotel in Sittingbourne
and comments from the Government minister Beverley Hughes."
Immigration minister Ms Hughes has demanded a review of
the business operations of Nass, the Home Office agency
responsible for induction centres, saying consultation had
not been good enough on plans to use 111 places at the Kent
hotel as an asylum induction centre. She said: "We
have to do much, much better."
Council leader Ken Bodfish, who attended the meeting, said:
"We have made it very clear to Nass that we believe
discussion and consultation to date has been very inadequate.
"However, no one here wishes to do anything which would
incite or inflame the ugly face of racism and I echo the
statements made by the Home Secretary David Blunkett along
these lines. "I am pleased this process has been put
on hold so the many outstanding issues and concerns can
be fully explored. This will clearly take several weeks,
if not longer, and nothing whatsoever will happen until
then.
"I hope the residents of Saltdean will recognise the
progress we have made." Meanwhile, Rottingdean ward
councillor David Smith said protesters might apply for an
injunction preventing asylum seekers staying at the Grand
Ocean pending a judicial review.
Coun Smith said: "When people are kept in the dark,
it is not surprising they start to fear the worst. "We
have been promised more consultation now, which hopefully
will include residents and not just council officers."
Saltdean Residents' Association planned to hold a demonstration
outside the hotel in Longridge Avenue on Saturday but this
may now be called off. Anita Officer, of Wicklands Avenue,
Saltdean, said: "The initial reaction to the latest
announcement was a sigh of relief but we cannot be lulled
into a false sense of security. "It is good to hear
Mr Blunkett recognises things are not being handled properly
but how long will it be before the next government U-turn?"
Marco Pasquale, chief executive of the hotel group, has
said the hotel would only take in a small number of asylum
seekers on a short term basis and accused opponents of scaremongering.
He said: "The amount of absolute nonsense that emanates
from Saltdean residents is unbelievable.
"The hotel, like many others in the Gatwick area,
has for many years provided various authorities with accommodation
rooms for assessment programmes for foreign individuals
legally residing in the UK. 'This kind of business involves
between six and 20 rooms and two meeting rooms for between
three and seven days' stay and is subject to availability.
"The more hysteria created, the more our businesses
will suffer and our houses devalue."
- Residents organise local protest SRA Meeting 25/01/03
1.30pm Evening Argus update 13/01/03 (and spot
the website mentions) Hotel defends asylum moves
by Karen Hoy
Managers say the Grand Ocean will remain a hotel
Managers at a hotel near Brighton have defended a plan
to take in asylum seekers, accusing their critics of whipping
up racism and hysteria. A storm of protest broke out after
we reported on Saturday that the Grand Ocean Hotel in Saltdean
would be used as emergency accommodation for immigration
arrivals, despite Government assurances to the contrary.
One Saltdean community web site was swamped with furious
emails from residents at the weekend. Some councillors also
expressed their anger, saying there would be "hell
to pay" if the hotel was filled with asylum seekers.
However, many residents have been dismayed by the response,
especially the managers of the hotel who said the matter
had been blown out of proportion. Marco Pasquale, chief
executive of the Grand Hotel Group Ltd, said the hotel would
not be swamped with large groups of asylum seekers. It would
cater for small numbers with professional qualifications
who had been found jobs under a deal struck by Home Secretary
David Blunkett, who has granted four-year work permits to
many asylum seekers." Mr Pasquale said the Grand Ocean
would continue to offer hotel accommodation and had already
booked out 80 per cent of its rooms for the current year.
He said the hotel would not be turned into a residential
home for asylum seekers. That would need permission from
Brighton and Hove City Council, and the management had no
intention of applying. Another member of staff at the hotel
said: "We have a huge duty to our customers who have
been coming here year after year. There is no way we would
jeopardise that. "It is not like it will be illegal
immigrants being kept in a hostel. These people will be
here legally." The Gatwick and Crawley Holiday Inns
are already taking part in a similar scheme, each housing
40 refugees, mainly men who have fled Iraq and Afghanistan.
Those at the hotels are free to come and go as they please
but are minded by a team of Home Office chaperones.
Many Saltdean residents have reacted angrily to the plan,
fearing the hotel would turn the town into a small-scale
version of now defunct Sangatte Red Cross refugee camp in
France. One of many letters published on the web site www.saltdean.info
says: "All Saltdean residents should be very concerned
about the Government's decision to allow asylum seekers
to use the Ocean Hotel. It has been shown time and time
again in different areas the crime rate rockets and the
house prices fall." Another letter said: "Very
few of the so-called asylum seekers coming into the country
at the moment appear to be genuine. Why are there so many
unattached young men? At best they are economic migrants
and at worst terrorists."
Others, however, say these comments are ill-informed. Another
letter on the Saltdean Info site said: "Having lived
in Saltdean for the last decade I am shocked at the reaction
that our usually community-minded town has had to the asylum
seekers staying at the Ocean Hotel."
Resident Marina Baker said: "People are ignorant to
what asylum seekers are and they are willing to treat them
in the way they were treated in their own countries, which
was the reason they left them. "We have Muslims living
in Saltdean and black people. Are we going to target them
as well? What concerns me is that some people are whipping
up feelings which are scaring people and old ladies."
Both the hotel management and residents were horrified by
racist graffiti daubed on a wall near the hotel during the
weekend. It has now been painted over. The Green Party has
urged local people and councillors to welcome asylum seekers.
Spokesman Simon Williams said: "It's time for some
compassion and a chance to show that the people of Brighton
and Hove are hospitable and welcoming to those in need."
Rottingdean and Saltdean councillor David Smith said in
a letter to colleagues: "I am amazed and disgusted
with the Labour Government's U-turn on asylum seekers being
accommodated at the Grand Ocean Hotel. "Doesn't this
prove that we, the general public, cannot trust them from
one month to the next?
"This volte-face will have far-reaching consequences
on social services, health services and education in the
city, particularly in the small community of Saltdean. "Will
the city council be able to cope with this additional burden
or will all services suffer as a consequence?"
- Asylum Seekers - a report of the SRA meeting of 25th
January (please note unofficial)
The SRA meeting began at 1.30 and the chair Evelyn George,
reported that it was the largest attendance for years (although
the last meeting must have come close). She stated that
Languard Alarms were offering a 50% discount to anyone booking
a security system if their leaflet was signed by a committee
member and Mrs George will continue to do this if in the
interest of local residents. She went on to welcome the
invited guests, Councillors Hyde, Smith, Hunt, Clayton and
our local MP Des Turner. Mrs George went onto reiterate
that the SRA was apolitical and that foul language was not
wanted. Also only one statement per person and all statement
to go through the chair. She also stated that it would be
nice to see people attend other meetings if they could.
The Resident - Duncan Ward explained that The Resident
which has come out this weekend in the leader and is available
at the Happy Shopper and the Post Offices was written before
the issue of Asylum Seekers blew up again so it was out
of date due to circumstances beyond SRA control.
Asylum Seekers - Dr Des Turner apologised to the floor
an explained that there had been confusion and that the
Home Office had stated that Saltdean was not an appropriate
place due to a number of reasons. He had been extremely
surprised over the Home Office U-turn. The National Asylum
Seeker Support Service (NASS) had had a change of staff
but this was still unacceptable. He underlined that there
had been NO contract signed by the hotel and wouldn't be
until a whole series of issues have been resolved. He was
quite optimistic that Saltdean would be turned down as an
induction centre but could give no guarantees. Sittingboune
( the other hotel in Kent in a similar position to the Ocean)
has apparently already signed a contract Counc. Smith addressed
the floor and referred to an unsigned statement put out
on Ocean Hotel paper that accused Couns. Hyde, Smith &
Clayton of stirring up trouble. He went onto question why
the Home Office was involved as many coastal hotel take
a small amount of asylum seekers. He also stated that he
felt local councillors had not been privy to Brighton and
Hove Council proceedings. He vigourously denied the claims
as slander.
One resident asked why there had been no consultation with
residents. The answer was that there was no formal consultative
process. Residents should write and voice their concerns
to Beverley Hughes, Minister of State at the Home Office.
Another resident asked if the Home Office was the sole
agent for discussion. Dr Turner answered that social services
and no direct role and that NASS was an 'arms length' government
agency. Although contract's needed signed ministerial approval
but we could complain to Des Turner who would campaign on
our behalf.
Councillor Hyde confirmed that local councillors had been
kept in the dark. She stated that she had been told that
although the project was supposed to have been on hold she
was told that there was an ongoing impact assessment on
Saltdean which seemed to contradict that.
One Resident stated that people were angry because they
felt that they were being kept in the dark. He stated that
Des Turner only tells us what he wants us to hear and that
we should keep the pressure up. Mrs George confirmed that
the pressure was certainly being kept up.
One resident queried whether representatives on Telscombe
Town Council were doing anything. Coun. Clayton confirmed
that letters had certainly been sent from T.T. Council,
including letters to Brighton and Hove Council requesting
information. Counc. Manning had written to Duncan ward and
has expressed his disgust and will be writing letters. Coun.
Clayton went onto say that he had had meetings with the
manager of the Ocean Hotel and been assured by him that
it was not being used for asylum seekers. He stated that
ESRA had had a social evening at the Ocean Hotel which had
been really well attended but went onto call ,what the manager
had said to him 'a pack of lies'.Counc. Lee of Telscombe
Cliffs also conformed that she has written to both B &
H council and the Ocean Hotel asking to be kept informed.
One resident expressed their disgust that 10 Labour councillors
had walked out of the meeting and their disgust at the excuse
of a clerical error being made.
One resident queried that links between the Ocean Hotel
and Arab Banks Plc based in Jersey. They queried a substantial
loss last year and their figures and debts of £21
million. Des Turner stated that he couldn't explain the
accounts. Some discussion had been made regarding a Leena(?)
homes but his was not confirmed or denied. Lots of companies
do offshore business he said. Mrs George stated that there
was nothing to stop any resident from finding out info from
company house.
Counc. Lee stated that she felt that the lack of information
had preyed on peoples fears and questioned whether 20 refugees
at the hotel was a problems the hotel had already been taking
bed and breakfast tenants for a while.
One resident stated he wished to work with the residents
of Saltdean to ensure that their fears would be groundless
question as to what Des Turner was doing was answered with
trying to voice complaints and work on behalf of residents
to prevent a contract and report progress when it came about.
A query as to whether the Manager of the Ocean Hotel was
invited was answered by Ms George with a no. Another query
about legal action by residents in Sittingbourne was clarified
by the fact that residents there were dealing with a signed
contract. Another local resident emphasised the need to
not have bigoted views.
Community centre
There was some discussion regarding the community centre.
Mrs George confirmed that we would not be giving up the
lease to the existing building until the new building was
ready to move into. They have agreed square footage - something
like 3200 - adequate for our needs.
There was a reminder of the AGM Monday 28th April (AGM)
7.30pm where there will be nominations for committee members.
Treasurers Report was a total of around £16000 -
some of which is reserved for a lift.
Counc. Lee had a reminder to send letters off to DEFRA
regarding the end of the South Downs Boundary at the Tye
and said that these needed to be in by the end of February.
You can print out the letters here. There seems to be 8
sites and many of those are unlikely so if they fail Portobello
could come back on the agenda.
Secretaries report by Duncan ward included the need to
support the Taxi Rider which id the only link for some people
to Peacehaven from east Saltdean. He stated that at present
Brighton and Hove Council did not have the required funding
for an A259 roundabout but would update progress later on
- apparently B + H Council are getting a large fund that
may be used to pay the £50,000 balance needed.
The registrar said that number of members was rising with
local issues but we still needed collectors for many roads.
The social secretary reported that the Book sale would
be held on the 15th February.
Helen Hicks from St Martins stated that she would be going
for planning permission for the Barn for a Pre-school and
afterschool club but they were on the bottom rung of a very
long ladder. She would be grateful for any resident who
could give her more history of the barn.
One resident asked if there would be a candidate from The
SRA running for election and Mrs George stated that this
was under consideration.
The meeting closed at 3.00 pm. Please email me here regarding
additions / amendments.
- News Report from Meridian TV - spot the website mention!
Row over asylum seekers hotel in Saltdean By Maidstone
Reporter
Jan 16, 2003, 11:30am
A row has broken out in East Sussex after the Government
gave permission for asylum seekers to live in a south coast
hotel. The Grand Ocean in Saltdean near Brighton could be
used as a halfway house for immigrants who already have
jobs under a new Home Office scheme. Racist graffiti daubed
on its walls has now been painted over, but a community
website for Saltdean has been bombarded with emails. Some
of the messages are from residents worried their community
will be swamped and others are concerned about persecution
by locals. "Do you want your children to be at risk,
general crime to spiral and the value of your property to
tumble?" says one. Another says; "I feel the whole
issue has been blown out of proportion and borders on racism."
There are also reports that leaflets from the right wing
British National Party have been put through people's letterboxes.
Brighton and Hove Councillor Keith Taylor told Meridian
News: "I think rather than fanning the flames of animosity,
we are given an opportunity to show an example of tolerance,
of compassion, and of humanity in seeking to cater for the
needs of very vulnerable people."The local councillor
for Saltdean, David Smith, says Government secrecy over
the decision has inflamed people's suspicions. He said:
"I think it's terrible anyone should be picked on or
victimised and I think it's a terrible situation. But I
honestly think that the asylum seeker situation has got
out of control and the Government doesn't know what to do
with it."While some fear their community may be overrun,
others are calling for compassion and understanding.
SRA note regarding the new Saltdean Resident (here)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
"The SRA January 2003 newsletter was produced and printed
prior to the news of 10th January 2003. It was too late
to amend the newsletter as it had already gone for distribution.
The newsletter is due to be distributed with the Leader
from Thursday this week. It is available in the Longridge
Avenue Post Office and the Saltdean Library.
The SRA is actively working with the local Councillors
on this sensitive issue. We are concerned about the effect
on local services but await further confirmation of the
proposed use of the local hotel.
Duncan Ward
Secretary
Saltdean Residents' Association
GOLDEN WEDDING CELEBRATIONS GREETINGS FROM AUSTRALIA FOR
SALTDEAN COUPLE
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Congratulations are sent to Terri & Gerald Pratten
of Saltdean from as far away as sunny Perth, Western Australia
as they celebrate their milestone Golden Wedding anniversary
on Friday 10 January 2003. Tina Eardley (nee Gilyead) contacted
us via the Internet and wrote "I will always be grateful
to Terri for being a great influence in changing the course
of my life over twenty years ago, Terri and I worked together
at ?the CEGB in the Computer Dept at Harrogate in North
Yorkshire" Apparently, Terri insisted that to travel
the world was apart from the challenge of adventure, it
also offered a great learning curve in life. After following
up on her suggestion to live and work in Germany for a German
lady she knew, Tina lived there for 3 years worked in Canada
for a few months and in 1984 she emigrated to Western Australia.
During these past 20 years Tina has kept in touch with Terri
& Gerald, and says "they are an exceptional couple
and I treasure them dearly" She would like them to
know she is thinking of them on their special day and wishes
them health & happiness for many years to come and is
forever grateful for Terri's guidance all those years ago.
- Stop Press: Ocean Hotel vandalism 12/01/03
by Adam Trimingham
Asylum seekers will be given a halfway house at a Sussex
hotel after a shock Government U-turn. In November, the
Home Office told Brighton and Hove City Council it would
not be using the Grand Ocean Hotel in Saltdean as emergency
accommodation for arrivals. But yesterday it was revealed
the Home Office changed its mind - to the fury of residents
who mounted a vigorous campaign against the application.
They say they have been misled by Home Secretary David Blunkett.
City council chief executive David Panter said the reversal
came as a surprise. It contradicted a letter from the Home
Office written only six weeks ago. The hotel had insisted
it had made no application to be considered as a temporary
hostel despite persistent rumours in the village. Mr Panter
last night told councillors: "The new letter states
the Home Office has now decided to contract bed spaces at
the Grand Ocean Hotel. "I can assure you we briefed
you in good faith in November that the Home Office would
not proceed with the application made by the hotel proprietors.
This letter has taken us all by surprise and we are clearly
concerned at this volte-face by the Home Office. "We
have contacted the Home Office Induction Centre project
manager by phone to verify the position. She will be visiting
next week to discuss details. Between now and then, we will
be doing all we can to clarify the situation and we will
continue to keep you informed at every opportunity."
Rottingdean and Saltdean Tory councillor David Smith said:
"I am disgusted. It does not make sense." Councillor
Lynda Hyde, who helped organise a meeting in the autumn
attended by 200 worried residents, said: "I am disgusted.
"There are 598 beds at the Grand Ocean Hotel and if
they are all taken up by asylum seekers there will be hell
to pay in this residential area. "The infrastructure
will be unable to cope with the special needs and requirements
of asylum seekers." No one from the hotel was available
for comment last night.
- Ocean Hotel News - © Argus 16/12/02
Hotel home for 40 immigrants by Deborah Tucknott
A group of refugees from the closed Sangatte camp in France
have been put up at a hotel in Sussex while they find work.
About 40 people from the former Red Cross camp are being
housed at the Holiday Inn at Gatwick for a maximum of three
months. They are among 1,200 Iraqis and Afghans Home Secretary
David Blunkett agreed to take in to the UK on four-year
work visas rather than as asylum seekers. The group at Gatwick
will be supported by the Government until its members find
work, either in Sussex or elsewhere in the country. On Saturday,
two buses took the final group of refugees at Sangatte,
mostly Iraqi Kurds, from the camp to England under a deal
struck between the British and French governments to shut
the centre. Sangatte became notorious after asylum seekers
used it as a base from which to launch illegal efforts to
reach the UK, often via the Channel Tunnel. The Home Office
said accommodating the refugees had only been possible as
a result of the unique deal struck with the French, which
includes tough new UK immigration controls on the French
side of the Channel to prevent illegal immigrants getting
to the UK. Crawley's Labour MP Laura Moffatt, who was told
of the group's arrival at Gatwick by the Home Office on
Friday, welcomed them to the county and hoped they would
add to the economy of the UK. She said: "They are very
welcome in my constituency as long as they behave and understand
that this is a great advantage that has been offered. I
look forward to them making a living. 'I completely and
utterly approve of the closure of Sangatte and the arrangement
they came to. To achieve that, the Home Office should be
very pleased with itself. It means a lot of people will
not illegally enter the UK through that route. ' People
from Afghanistan and Iraq have a genuine need to be here.
Many of them will start work long before the three-month
period." The Iraqi Kurds are mainly men with skills,
and include builders and mechanics. Among the Afghans are
families who already have relatives in the UK and are not
considered asylum seekers by the Home Office, which is working
with local authorities to find them permanent accommodation.
A spokesman said: "The majority of them have been really
positive. They want to come here to work and are really
eager to work." T here is now vastly improved security
at Calais and Frethun. Freight searching in Calais will
soon be 100 per cent and hi-tech detection equipment is
being deployed along the north European coast. The refugees'
skills are being identified and the Home Office said it
was already pursuing offers from potential employers. Labour
councillor Douglas Murdoch, leader of Crawley Borough Council,
said: "The hotel industry is very underutilized at
this time of year. 'The Holiday Inn is quite happy to take
them. They are causing no problem. I think it is a very
Christmassy act." Sussex police at Gatwick have been
told they are staying at the hotel. I inspector Paul Drake
said: "We are not expecting any problems. 'We are not
putting any special measures in place. We are aware we might
see some of them at terminals and walking around the airport."
Brighton and Hove was not put forward as a base for short-term
asylum seekers, despite unfounded rumours the Ocean Hotel
in Saltdean would take them in. But the Adelphi Hotel in
Hastings was selected as a temporary home for 60 asylum
seekers when the closure of Sangatte was announced.
|